Michigan · utility comparison
Consumers Energy vs Great Lakes Energy: electricity rates compared
Great Lakes Energy was cheaper in 2025: its residential customers paid 20.32¢ per kWh, against 20.66¢ at Consumers Energy, all charges included. That is 2% more per kWh at Consumers Energy. At the Michigan average usage of 635 kWh a month, the same home would pay about $131 with Consumers Energy and $129 with Great Lakes Energy, a gap of $2 a month ($26 a year).
Average residential price, 2025
Cents per kWh, all charges included
Side by side
| Consumers Energy | Great Lakes Energy | |
|---|---|---|
| Average price per kWh, 2025 | 20.66¢ | 20.32¢ |
| Average monthly bill, 2025 | $134 | $128 |
| Average use, kWh a month | 649 | 632 |
| Bill at 635 kWh (state average use) | $131 | $129 |
| Time without power per customer | 13 h 40 min | 73 h 21 min |
| Outages per customer | 1.4 | 4.1 |
| Residential customers | 1,662,741 | 123,277 |
| Type | investor-owned utility | electric cooperative |
| Time-of-use plans on file | 2 | 0 |
Bold marks the lower value (lower price, bill, outage time). Prices are all-in averages: residential revenue divided by kWh sold.
What the numbers say
- Outages: the average Consumers Energy customer was without power for 13 h 40 min in 2025, against 73 h 21 min for Great Lakes Energy, including major events.
- As an investor-owned utility, Consumers Energy has its rates set by the state utility commission after public rate cases.
- As a member-owned electric cooperative, Great Lakes Energy sets its rates through its elected board; in most states the utility commission has limited or no say over co-op rates.
- Consumers Energy time-of-use schedules on file: Residential Smart Hours Rate (RSH), Residential Summer On-Peak Basic Service (RSP).
Where both utilities serve
Consumers Energy and Great Lakes Energy both reported residential customers in 26 Michigan counties: Allegan, Antrim, Barry, Charlevoix, Cheboygan, Clare, Crawford, Emmet, Grand Traverse, Kalkaska, Kent, Lake and 14 more. Within these counties the utility depends on the exact address. Michigan also has retail choice in parts of the state: where it applies to investor-owned utilities, you can buy the energy from a competitive supplier while the utility keeps delivering it.
Consumers Energy rates Great Lakes Energy rates All Michigan utilities
Questions
Is Consumers Energy cheaper than Great Lakes Energy?
No. Great Lakes Energy was cheaper per kWh in 2025: 20.32¢ against 20.66¢ at Consumers Energy, all charges included. At the same usage of 635 kWh a month, the difference is about $2 a month.
Can I switch from Consumers Energy to Great Lakes Energy?
Not by choice. Each address is served by one utility, set by its location. Both serve parts of 26 Michigan counties, so neighbours can be on different utilities. Your bill, or each utility's service-area map, tells you which one serves an address. Michigan also has retail choice in parts of the state: where it applies to investor-owned utilities, you can buy the energy from a competitive supplier while the utility keeps delivering it.
Which has fewer power outages, Consumers Energy or Great Lakes Energy?
Consumers Energy: its customers were without power for 13 h 40 min on average in 2025, against 73 h 21 min, including major events, as reported to EIA.
Sources: EIA Form 861 (2025, final) and Form 861M (2026, preliminary); OpenEI Utility Rate Database. How we calculate these figures.