Florida · utility comparison
FPL vs Clay Electric Cooperative: electricity rates compared
Clay Electric Cooperative was cheaper in 2025: its residential customers paid 14.02¢ per kWh, against 14.62¢ at FPL, all charges included. That is 4% more per kWh at FPL. At the Florida average usage of 1,103 kWh a month, the same home would pay about $161 with FPL and $155 with Clay Electric Cooperative, a gap of $7 a month ($79 a year).
Average residential price, 2025
Cents per kWh, all charges included
Side by side
| FPL | Clay Electric Cooperative | |
|---|---|---|
| Average price per kWh, 2025 | 14.62¢ | 14.02¢ |
| Average monthly bill, 2025 | $162 | $171 |
| Average use, kWh a month | 1,111 | 1,220 |
| Bill at 1,103 kWh (state average use) | $161 | $155 |
| Time without power per customer | 47 min | 3 h 25 min |
| Outages per customer | 0.5 | 2.6 |
| Residential customers | 5,337,118 | 173,966 |
| Type | investor-owned utility | electric cooperative |
| Time-of-use plans on file | 1 | 0 |
Bold marks the lower value (lower price, bill, outage time). Prices are all-in averages: residential revenue divided by kWh sold.
What the numbers say
- Clay Electric Cooperative homes use 10% more electricity than FPL homes (1,220 vs 1,111 kWh a month), so their average bills differ less than their prices do.
- Outages: the average FPL customer was without power for 47 min in 2025, against 3 h 25 min for Clay Electric Cooperative, including major events.
- As an investor-owned utility, FPL has its rates set by the state utility commission after public rate cases.
- As a member-owned electric cooperative, Clay Electric Cooperative sets its rates through its elected board; in most states the utility commission has limited or no say over co-op rates.
- FPL time-of-use schedules on file: RTR-1 Residential Service TOU.
Where both utilities serve
FPL and Clay Electric Cooperative both reported residential customers in 11 Florida counties: Alachua, Baker, Bradford, Clay, Columbia, Duval, Flagler, Putnam, Suwannee, Union, Volusia. Within these counties the utility depends on the exact address.
Florida Power & Light (FPL) rates Clay Electric Cooperative rates All Florida utilities
Questions
Is FPL cheaper than Clay Electric Cooperative?
No. Clay Electric Cooperative was cheaper per kWh in 2025: 14.02¢ against 14.62¢ at FPL, all charges included. At the same usage of 1,103 kWh a month, the difference is about $7 a month.
Can I switch from FPL to Clay Electric Cooperative?
Not by choice. Each address is served by one utility, set by its location. Both serve parts of 11 Florida counties, so neighbours can be on different utilities. Your bill, or each utility's service-area map, tells you which one serves an address.
Which has fewer power outages, FPL or Clay Electric Cooperative?
FPL: its customers were without power for 47 min on average in 2025, against 3 h 25 min, including major events, as reported to EIA.
Sources: EIA Form 861 (2025, final) and Form 861M (2026, preliminary); OpenEI Utility Rate Database. How we calculate these figures.