California · utility comparison
PG&E vs SMUD: electricity rates compared
SMUD was cheaper in 2025: its residential customers paid 18.93¢ per kWh, against 37.52¢ at PG&E, all charges included. That is 98% more per kWh at PG&E. At the California average usage of 494 kWh a month, the same home would pay about $185 with PG&E and $94 with SMUD, a gap of $92 a month ($1,102 a year).
Average residential price, 2025
Cents per kWh, all charges included
Side by side
| PG&E | SMUD | |
|---|---|---|
| Average price per kWh, 2025 | 37.52¢ | 18.93¢ |
| Average price per kWh, 2026 so far | 36.74¢ | 19.82¢ |
| Average monthly bill, 2025 | $174 | $125 |
| Average use, kWh a month | 464 | 663 |
| Bill at 494 kWh (state average use) | $185 | $94 |
| Time without power per customer | 4 h 33 min | 50 min |
| Outages per customer | 1.6 | 0.9 |
| Residential customers | 1,738,444 | 601,275 |
| Type | investor-owned utility | public power district |
| Time-of-use plans on file | 5 | 0 |
Bold marks the lower value (lower price, bill, outage time). Prices are all-in averages: residential revenue divided by kWh sold.
What the numbers say
- PG&E: January–August 2026 average of 36.74¢, 2% below its 2025 average.
- SMUD: January–August 2026 average of 19.82¢, 5% above its 2025 average.
- SMUD homes use 43% more electricity than PG&E homes (663 vs 464 kWh a month), so their average bills differ less than their prices do.
- Outages: the average SMUD customer was without power for 50 min in 2025, against 4 h 33 min for PG&E, including major events.
- As an investor-owned utility, PG&E has its rates set by the state utility commission after public rate cases.
- As a public power district, SMUD has its rates set by its own elected or appointed board.
- PG&E time-of-use schedules on file: E-ELEC Residential Time of Use (Electric Home), E-TOU-C Residential Time of Use Baseline Region P, E-TOU-C Residential Time of Use Baseline Region P (All Electric Service).
PG&E vs SMUD: average residential price by month, 2026
Cents per kWh, all charges included
- PG&E
- SMUD
Where both utilities serve
PG&E and SMUD both reported residential customers in 3 California counties: Placer, Sacramento, Yolo. Within these counties the utility depends on the exact address.
Questions
Is PG&E cheaper than SMUD?
No. SMUD was cheaper per kWh in 2025: 18.93¢ against 37.52¢ at PG&E, all charges included. At the same usage of 494 kWh a month, the difference is about $92 a month.
Can I switch from PG&E to SMUD?
Not by choice. Each address is served by one utility, set by its location. Both serve parts of 3 California counties, so neighbours can be on different utilities. Your bill, or each utility's service-area map, tells you which one serves an address.
Which has fewer power outages, PG&E or SMUD?
SMUD: its customers were without power for 50 min on average in 2025, against 4 h 33 min, including major events, as reported to EIA.
Sources: EIA Form 861 (2025, final) and Form 861M (2026, preliminary); OpenEI Utility Rate Database. How we calculate these figures.